How to Properly Set a Mouse Trap (and Actually Catch One)

You know what time it is. The air is getting colder, the evenings are shorter, and somewhere under your sink or behind your walls, tiny feet are starting to move. It’s fall—and that means mice are moving in. Your home feels warm and safe, and to them, that’s an open invitation. Once a single mouse finds its way through a small crack or gap, it doesn’t take long before you start hearing scratching at night or finding small droppings near the pantry. Before they start nesting and multiplying, you need to take control.

Many homeowners think catching a few mice will solve the problem, but the truth is, where there’s one, there’s usually more. Female mice can have litters every few weeks, and before long, your small problem becomes a full-blown infestation. Acting early makes all the difference.

Why Common Fixes Don’t Work

The first instinct for many people is to reach for something quick and easy. Some try peppermint oil, hoping the strong scent will drive the mice away. Others plug in ultrasonic repellents that promise to keep rodents at bay using high-frequency sounds. These tricks might seem harmless and convenient, but the results are often disappointing. Mice are resourceful. They quickly adapt to smells and sounds, and once they find food and warmth, it takes more than a few drops of oil or an electric buzz to make them leave.

Glue traps are another common option, but they come with downsides. They can be messy, inhumane, and often fail to solve the root issue. You might catch one mouse, but others will simply avoid the area. Live traps can work if you have patience and discipline, but you need to check them often and release the mice far enough away—otherwise, they’ll simply find their way back. These methods can feel like progress at first, but they rarely get to the heart of the problem.

The Trap That Still Works Best

When it comes to actually getting results, the classic snap mouse trap still stands as the most effective tool. It’s simple, fast, and proven. But like anything that works, success depends on how you use it. Setting a mouse trap seems straightforward, but most people do it wrong. They load too much bait, handle it with bare hands, or place the trap in open areas where mice never travel. Mice are cautious creatures that move along walls and tight spaces. If your trap isn’t in their path, it might as well not be there.

Setting It Right

If you’ve ever set a trap only to find the bait gone and the trap untouched, you’re not alone. The difference between catching one mouse and catching them all comes down to technique. The bait should be sticky, like peanut butter, applied in a small amount deep enough that the mouse must tug at it. The trap should sit perpendicular to the wall with the trigger facing the wall. That way, when a mouse runs along its usual route, it encounters the bait naturally.

Placement is everything. That’s where we come in.

At Montana Pest Solutions, we specialize in mice control—from inspection to exclusion. We know where they hide, how they move, and the smartest way to keep them out permanently.

Still want to try it yourself first? No problem. We’ve got your back.

Click the link below or send us an email, and we’ll send you a step-by-step video guide on how to set a mouse trap like a pro—no wasted bait, no missed catches.

I need the step-by-step video guide